The Seagulls had announced plans to remove the Heritage Tile Wall, which contains more than 2,500 tiles paid for by fans. It had been claimed the wall had deteriorated to the point where it needed replacing.
But after a fans' backlash, management have now backed down and insist while the wall will be replaced, the messages will stay. Brighton had originally suggested a "virtual" wall to maintain the messages.
"We are aware that the club's decision to find a new format to recreate and preserve the messages on the heritage tiles has caused distress to some fans and confusion for others. We are very sorry for this," chairman Paul Barber wrote in a letter to fans.
"We are fully aware that many tiles represent significant sentimental and emotional moments and connections in people's lives, hence our desire to protect and preserve the messages.
"In looking at all new options, we have listened very carefully to the heartfelt feedback we have received in the past few days and we will not merge the heritage messages with the new 125 wall as originally proposed."