Last year's Johnny Warren Medalist Joel Griffiths slotted a last-minute penalty to give both teams a share of the points in front of 16,000 fans after an 87th minute header from Olyroo substitute Matt Simon.
Newcastle seemed to control most of the contest but it was the true grit and determination of the visitors that stemmed the tide and then managed to have a grasp on all three points against the run of play.
However it was not to be as referee Matthew Breeze pointed to the spot in injury time to give the Jets a share of the spoils.