Liverpool defender Virgil van Dijk was slammed by pundits for Chelsea's equaliser in Sunday's 2-2 draw.
A ball over the top caught out Liverpool 's high-line as Pulisic cooly slotted home to complete a quick-fire turnaround.
Pulisic found himself in acres of space to pick his spot - and ex-Reds captain Graeme Souness was baffled as to why Van Dijk did not make more of an effort to get across and block the shot.
Speaking at half-time on Sky Sports, Souness said: “Why has Van Dijk not come across there?
“He's just running in a straight line back to his goal.
“Come over, come over, come over - he's not even sprinting."
Former Chelsea striker Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink went a step further as he questioned Van Dijk's effort, adding: “It's lazy, isn't it?"
Jamie Carragher, meanwhile, blamed Liverpool's “obsession" with playing offside and keeping in line as they got caught out.
Carragher said: “They've got an obsession, Liverpool's centre-backs, you see this a lot where they always stay in line with each other.
“They never cover each other - there's an obsession with playing offside.
“We noticed that right throughout the game, the space between the two centre-backs is too big.
“Initially, his starting position, Van Dijk, because he's not intense enough to get over, he doesn't want to cover his other centre-back.
“He stays in the same line, and that's why he's too far to get across."