As featured on NewsNow: Football news

Phil Chisnall: How it feels to be replaced by a Man Utd player at Liverpool

When Phil Chisnall left Manchester United for Liverpool in 1964, nobody would have believed he would be the last player transferred directly between the two clubs.

In those days, under the stewardship of Bill Shankly, Liverpool were the up and coming force in English football. Manchester United were the established one.

There was always rivalry between the two cities, but as former Reds midfielder George Scott explains, Liverpool's fiercest opponent on the football pitch in those days were their Merseyside neighbours, Everton.

“(The Chisnall move) wasn't controversial as what it would be now. Liverpool's biggest rivals then were Everton," Scott told “There wasn't so much of a rivalry yet between United and Liverpool."

Liverpool would become the dominant club in the English top-flight over the next two decades until Sir Alex Ferguson turned the tide for United in the 1990's.

While the likes of Peter Beardsley and Michael Owen played for both clubs, only Chisnall moved directly between the two.

Indeed, Chisnall's transfer symbolises how the rivalry has grown into one of the biggest in world football. But for Scott, the move meant much more.

At the time, Scott was just a youngster trying to break into Shankly's star-studded first-team, having arrived at the club in 1959.

The acquisition of Chisnall pushed Scott out of Liverpool's preseason tour of the United States. He left the club a year later.

“It was a bad thing for me. Because I was on the brink of the first-team at the time," Scott explained.

“I was top scorer in the reserves and I was within four or five days before going to America for a preseason tour.

“I got my suit, my injections, everything. And then Shankly called me into the office and said there is only 16 places on the tour, and we've signed Phil Chisnall and he's got to come with us. He never really gave me a proper explanation why I was the one who missed out.

“A couple of people went that didn't have the experience that I had. It was disappointing. He said go home, next season is an important one for you. It was disappointing because I would've broken through on that tour."

About the author

Paul Vegas

Have your say

Subscribe and go ad-free

For only $10 a year

  1. Go Ad-Free
  2. Faster site experience
  3. Support great writing
  4. Subscribe now
Launch Offer: 2 months free

Subscribe and go ad-free

For only $10 a year

Subscribe now
Launch Offer: 2 months free