Is PSV's Jason Culina talking his way out of Australia team?
EDITORIAL: Is Jason Culina talking his way out of the Australia team?
Culina's claims, that his move to Gold Coast United will not affect his international chances, may sit well with the elites in the soccer media, but how does his rivals for a place in Pim Verbeek's midfield take such comments? Indeed, does the coach himself accept such a boast?
There's no doubt at present the PSV Eindhoven midfielder is among Australia's top 20 footballers. But a first-choice? If Verbeek was to employ the diamond midfield he did so successfully at the beginning of this World Cup qualifying campaign - and with everyone fit - where would you select Culina? Vince Grella, now with Blackburn Rovers, wouldn't be dislodged from his defensive role, Everton's Tim Cahill would sit behind the strikers, with Harry Kewell, of Galatasaray, and Grella's teammate Brett Emerton hugging the wings. And if Grella was to breakdown, the growing claims of Grosseto midfielder Carl Valeri surely cannot be cast side.
The next 18 months could be career-defining for Valeri. He enjoys an excellent reputation in Italy and is now being coveted by several mid-table Serie A clubs.
Brought to Italy by Inter Milan, Valeri spent almost four years outside the top two divisions learning his craft. While his peers would have pulled up stumps and returned home, Valeri stuck it out and now is on the verge of reaping the rewards with a potential summer move to Italy's top-flight and a place in Australia's World Cup squad.
Should we just expect Valeri to simply duff his cap to Culina and meekly stand aside? Unlike the new Gold Coast signing, Valeri has had to work hard for every scrap of recognition he's received in the local press. There's been no media campaign to get him selected for the national team. Indeed, for his international debut two years ago against China, those close to Valeri tell me he wasn't even on the original standby list! It was only after so many withdrawals that Valeri was given his chance - and he hasn't looked back since.
The exciting thing about Verbeek is that Australia's squads, for the first time in years, has no whiff of favourites or cliques. He won't be swayed by outside media pressure and so Culina's decision to return to Australia can only be good news for Valeri - and even Brett Holman, who will be playing Champions League football next season with AZ Alkmaar.
Make no mistake, there will be tears before the final squad is selected for South Africa. Culina is the soccer clique's cause celebre and they will revel in piling the pressure on Verbeek to select him.
It won't matter if Valeri is running around in the stadiums of Rome and Turin next season, or Holman is scoring goals across Europe, they will demand Culina be selected.
And if Culina does tumble out of Verbeek's first XI, it won't be because of the form and sacrifice of those selected ahead of him. It will be because Verbeek has no time for the A-League nor it's local talent. It will be all manufactured, of course, by an ex-players' brigade still struggling to come to grips with a national coach who refuses to be cosied up to like a 'Viddie', a 'Kossie' or an 'Arnie'.
And that's why Culina will have it all to do in the coming A-League season. He can talk about his place "not being in jeopardy" and that will be lapped up by the local media, but Verbeek has shown he's prepared to make unpopular calls if it means Australia continue winning.
Like never before, there is an opportunity for a Valeri or Holman, by simply playing well (who would have thought it?), of earning themselves a start at next year's World Cup.
Tribal Games
Tribalfootball Store
- home
- News
- Leagues
- A-League
- Argentine Primera División
- English Premier League
- Football League One
- French Ligue 2
- German Bundesliga 2
- Scottish Premier League
- Swiss Challenge League
- Swiss Super League
- Belgian First Division
- Brazil Serie B
- Campeonato Brasileiro Série A
- Chinese Super League
- English Championship
- Eredivisie
- German Bundesliga
- Italian Serie A
- Italian Serie B
- Italian Serie C1
- J-League
- Ligue 1
- MLS
- Portuguese Liga
- Prva HNL
- Russian Premier League
- Segunda División
- Segunda División B
- Spanish Liga
- Super League Greece
- Turkish Super Lig
- transfer news
- Results & Fixtures
- football store
- video games
Results & Fixtures
Matches
| Home | Away | Score | Time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fri Feb 17th | |||
| Melbourne Heart | Gold Coast United | - | 09:00 |
| Sat Feb 18th | |||
| Central Coast Mariners | Wellington Phoenix | - | 06:30 |
| Brisbane Roar | Melbourne Victory | - | 08:45 |
| Perth Glory | Newcastle Jets | - | 11:00 |
| Sun Feb 19th | |||
| Adelaide United | Sydney | - | 06:00 |
Tables
| Team | P | W | D | L | GD | PTS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Central Coast Mariners | 20 | 12 | 4 | 4 | 14 | 40 |
| Brisbane Roar | 21 | 10 | 5 | 6 | 16 | 35 |
| Wellington Phoenix | 21 | 10 | 3 | 8 | 5 | 33 |
| Perth Glory | 21 | 9 | 4 | 8 | 4 | 31 |
| Newcastle Jets | 21 | 8 | 4 | 9 | -2 | 28 |
| Melbourne Heart | 21 | 7 | 6 | 8 | -1 | 27 |
| Sydney | 21 | 7 | 6 | 8 | -7 | 27 |
| Melbourne Victory | 21 | 5 | 10 | 6 | -5 | 25 |
| Adelaide United | 21 | 5 | 8 | 8 | -13 | 23 |
| Gold Coast United | 20 | 3 | 6 | 11 | -11 | 15 |
Related Stories
- Jan 23 PLAY IT SHORT (A-LEAGUE): Victory to raid Man Utd training ground, Berger could be anything, Cahill won't leave Everton
- Jan 24 Everton keeper Howard happy Cahill broke his duck
- Jan 22 Everton boss Moyes happy to see Cahill break scoring duck
- Jan 22 Everton boss Moyes concedes Blackburn draw was fortunate
- Jan 21 PREMIER LEAGUE: Cahill scores but Everton held by Blackburn
Popular Stories
- Feb 14 Ronaldo hands Florentino Real Madrid contract nightmare
- Feb 14 Real Madrid coach Mourinho prepared to replace Casillas with new keeper signing
- Feb 14 Man Utd agreement for Gaitan still watertight with Benfica
- Feb 14 Man City rebel Tevez: Man Utd stars, Ferguson are the BEST!
- Feb 14 Chelsea players attacked AVB, Cech in crisis meeting


Comments (8)
Brett Holman is not in the first XI and does not know where the goals are if they stared directly at him. Valeri shows promise but does the Socceroos need 2 holding midfielders?
Hang on a minute, all of you who saying that culina is "one of the first" or "in the top 4" players picked for the national team are absolutely joking yourself. By saying this you are totally discrediting the rest of your argument.
Now Im not saying that Culina is a terrible player, infact quite the opposite, he is really quite deserving of his place in Australia's starting XI... BUT one of the first names on the teamsheet? no way! Schwarzer, Cahill, Kewell, Emerton, Niell, Bresciano, McDonald, are all players that are of a standard that Culina can not hope to reach. Maybe he is on par with players such as Grella and Kennedy, or as the article mentioned; Valeri and Holman.
On current form, sure, Culina should be in and around the starting XI, bench atleast. BUT as the article also questions, can he keep up the standard of football that he is playing at the moment? Common belief and logic says no. He is going from a team which often qualifies for the Champions League, to an unknown entity in a lowly Australian league (I am an A-League fan). There is NO way he can keep up the standard, it is just not possible.
Great article Chris, keep it up.
No doubt I will get heavily slated by idiots after posting this... Oh well.
Why pick on his father now? Jealous???
Your Fathers a half wit ;) have then apples.
Post new comment