The Uruguay international is under consideration at United as a long-term successor for Rio Ferdinand.
O Jogo says United chief scout Martin Ferguson was in the stands to watch Garay in action against Beira-Mar.
Also of interest to Ferguson was Garay's teammate Nicolas Gaitan, who has been a long-term target for United manager Sir Alex Ferguson.
Is a new centre-half needed at United? Would Garay be the right deal? Give us your shout below...